Arguing That Health Mandate Is Not a Tax, Except When It Is

Arguing That Health Mandate Is Not a Tax, Except When It Is : Photo Gallery

Supreme Court Justices: Health Care 'Individual Mandate' Is Not A Tax Supreme Court Justices: Health Care 'Individual Mandate' Is Not A Tax In the first day of arguments over Obama's health care law (the Affordable	Health Care Mandate Is a Tax, Except It Is Not a Tax | Indecision ... Health Care Mandate Is a Tax, Except It Is Not a Tax | Indecision ... Health Care Mandate Is a Tax, Except It Is Not a Tax	Secretary Sebelius: Individual Mandate is Not a Tax | House ... Secretary Sebelius: Individual Mandate is Not a Tax | House ... This is the linchpin of what	The Individual Mandate's Tax Troubles - Hit & Run : Reason Magazine The Individual Mandate's Tax Troubles - Hit & Run : Reason Magazine Not a tax? Whatever!
Budget Director Undercuts Regime's Obamacare Supreme Court ... Budget Director Undercuts Regime's Obamacare Supreme Court ... How is that not a tax increase	Live Blog: 'Obamacare' Challenged at the Supreme Court - Yahoo! News Live Blog: 'Obamacare' Challenged at the Supreme Court - Yahoo! News Tomorrow's arguments have to	Why The Supreme Court Should Strike Down Health Care Reform's ... Why The Supreme Court Should Strike Down Health Care Reform's ... insurance is not a tax.	Health Care Lawsuits - Lawsuit Timeline Health Care Lawsuits - Lawsuit Timeline Mandate: That's Not a Tax
SCOTUS skeptical of idea that mandate is a tax | Campaign 2012 ... SCOTUS skeptical of idea that mandate is a tax | Campaign 2012 ... of oral arguments did not	Catholic Letter Denounces Health Care Contraceptive Mandate ... Catholic Letter Denounces Health Care Contraceptive Mandate ... The Church's vocal arguments	The Left Call : now with 99% more liberal bias The Left Call : now with 99% more liberal bias Supreme Court Justices: Health Care 'Individual Mandate' Is Not A Tax	OBAMACARE INDIVIDUAL MANDATE: IS IT TO BE A TAX OR NOT A TAX THAT ... OBAMACARE INDIVIDUAL MANDATE: IS IT TO BE A TAX OR NOT A TAX THAT ... a tax or is it not a tax?
Individual Health Insurance Mandate is Not a Difficult ... Individual Health Insurance Mandate is Not a Difficult ... rhetorical force not from	Florida Politics: News on the parties, politicians, policies ... Florida Politics: News on the parties, politicians, policies ... “Floridians should not have	Health Care Mandate Is a Tax, Except It Is Not a Tax | Indecision ... Health Care Mandate Is a Tax, Except It Is Not a Tax | Indecision ... Health Care Mandate Is a Tax, Except It Is Not a Tax | Indecision Blog	John McCain | Fox News Insider John McCain | Fox News Insider health insurance—is not
... Arguing in Court That the Health Care Individual Mandate Is a Tax ... Arguing in Court That the Health Care Individual Mandate Is a Tax	Now Barack Obama Says the Health Insurance Mandate is a Tax - Health ... Now Barack Obama Says the Health Insurance Mandate is a Tax - Health ...	OBAMACARE INDIVIDUAL MANDATE: IS IT TO BE A TAX OR NOT A TAX THAT IS ... OBAMACARE INDIVIDUAL MANDATE: IS IT TO BE A TAX OR NOT A TAX THAT IS ...	... political cartoon Obama Admin: We Lied, Health Care Mandate IS a Tax ... political cartoon Obama Admin: We Lied, Health Care Mandate IS a Tax
Tax? Not a tax? Whatever! Tax? Not a tax? Whatever!	Randy E. Barnett: The Insurance Mandate in Peril - WSJ.com Randy E. Barnett: The Insurance Mandate in Peril - WSJ.com	that the individual mandate to purchase health insurance is not a tax ... that the individual mandate to purchase health insurance is not a tax ...	... doubles down on argument that state health mandate is conservative ... doubles down on argument that state health mandate is conservative
... doubles down on argument that state health mandate is conservative ... doubles down on argument that state health mandate is conservative	Government Arguing That Health Insurance Premiums Are Really Taxes ... Government Arguing That Health Insurance Premiums Are Really Taxes ...	... , Me, and the Massachusetts Health Care Mandate | Mitt Romney Central ... , Me, and the Massachusetts Health Care Mandate | Mitt Romney Central	Ave Maria fighting contraception mandate - ABC-7.com WZVN News for ... Ave Maria fighting contraception mandate - ABC-7.com WZVN News for ...
... employer mandate requiring businesses to cover workers or pay a tax ... employer mandate requiring businesses to cover workers or pay a tax	Argumentation About Tax On Text by Bernardo Argumentation About Tax On Text by Bernardo	DIGEST 3rd ed. by Pat Kittler © 2010, 2011 The Facts About Health ... DIGEST 3rd ed. by Pat Kittler © 2010, 2011 The Facts About Health ...	the first intention of the mandate is to impede health the first intention of the mandate is to impede health
ARGUING THAT HEALTH MANDATE IS NOT A TAX, EXCEPT WHEN IT IS ARGUING THAT HEALTH MANDATE IS NOT A TAX, EXCEPT WHEN IT IS To do that, it has relied on legal semantics to argue that the insurance mandate will be enforced through the tax code even though Congress took pains to label it a penalty and not a tax. After losing that argument in a lower court, the government's ...	Obama Lawyer Laughed at In Supreme Court Obama Lawyer Laughed at In Supreme Court On the first day of health care reform arguments before the Supreme Court, two justices needled a top Obama lawyer for simultaneously calling the fine that will be paid under the law for not purchasing insurance a “penalty” and a “tax.	Supreme Court begins debating sweeping health care law Supreme Court begins debating sweeping health care law In an unusual twist, the Obama administration is now siding with the law's opponents and strongly argued the mandate is not a tax. The high court actually designated a Washington private attorney, Robert Long, to argue in favor of the tax question.	Justices Seem Intent To Get To The Heart Of The Health Care Law Justices Seem Intent To Get To The Heart Of The Health Care Law The brief, Totenberg said, warned that the federal government could expect a flood of lawsuits on other tax matters if the mandate is not found to be a tax. Listen Live At 8 pm Monday: The Supreme Court has wrapped the first day of oral arguments on ...
Supreme Court Begins Hearing Challenges to Unconstitutional Obamacare Provisions Supreme Court Begins Hearing Challenges to Unconstitutional Obamacare Provisions GMU's Somin rebuts the “everyone uses healthcare” argument for Obamacare here. The Cato Institute's briefs, which CEI joined, explain why Obamacare's individual mandate is not valid under the Constitution's Interstate Commerce Clause and tax provisions ...	Health-care challenge at US Supreme Court: Justices seek way past Day 1 hurdle Health-care challenge at US Supreme Court: Justices seek way past Day 1 hurdle Instead, such lawsuits challenging any tax or assessment must be filed after the tax or assessment has been paid. This AIA requirement would undercut the current challenge to the health-care law because the so-called individual mandate will not be ...	Reading Between The Lines Of Monday's Supreme Court Arguments Reading Between The Lines Of Monday's Supreme Court Arguments Moreover, this is not in the Internal Revenue Code but for purposes of collection." The penalty, Breyer added, is "not attached to a tax. It is attached to a health care requirement." That it's being "collected in the same manner as a tax," he said, ...	Q&A on the health care showdown in the Supreme Court Q&A on the health care showdown in the Supreme Court WASHINGTON — The most controversial requirement in President Barack Obama's health care law is that all Americans get health insurance. On Tuesday, the Supreme Court will hear arguments over whether this mandate is constitutional.
Is health care reform good for business? Depends on who you ask. Is health care reform good for business? Depends on who you ask. “We'll adjust our business model for that, and that drives whether or not we hire,” said Capstone Mechanical owner Rick Tullis. This week, the National Federation of Independent Business, along with 26 states, will argue that the health reform law's ...	Q&A on the health care showdown in the Supreme Court Q&A on the health care showdown in the Supreme Court WASHINGTON -- The most controversial requirement in President Barack Obama's health care law is that all Americans get health insurance. On Tuesday, the Supreme Court will hear arguments over whether this mandate is constitutional.	Supreme Court Begins Review of Affordable Care Act Supreme Court Begins Review of Affordable Care Act But the justices' questions Monday morning suggested that they did not think the insurance penalty was tantamount to a tax. An obscure 1867 law prohibits legal challenges to a tax until it has been collected. The penalty for not having health insurance ...	Supreme Court takes up fight over Obama healthcare overhaul Supreme Court takes up fight over Obama healthcare overhaul By STEVEN R. HURST AP March 26, 2012 10:48AM Supporters of the health care reform law signed by President Obama gather in front of the Supreme Court in Washington, Monday, March 26, 2012, as the court begins three days of arguments on health care.
The Morning Ledger: Court Could Bring Clarity on Health Care The Morning Ledger: Court Could Bring Clarity on Health Care The main issue is whether the individual mandate is constitutional, but today the arguments focus on whether the penalty for not buying insurance is a tax. This is huge because if the justices decide that it is a tax, they can't take up the case until ...	Lawyers cram for epic review before justices Lawyers cram for epic review before justices The problem, said Paul D. Clement, who represents the 26 states challenging the law, is not just the length of the arguments that the court will hear, but the variety of topics to be addressed. The law itself is a sprawling revision of the health care ...	'Obamacare' under 3 days of arguments before Supreme Court 'Obamacare' under 3 days of arguments before Supreme Court At issue on the first day is whether the court can even settle the mandate provision, which does not go into effect until 2014, or whether it must await a challenge from a citizen who has refused to comply and been subjected to the penalty. Argument on ...	Justices ready to move to heart of health case Justices ready to move to heart of health case The Supreme Court will begin hearing arguments on Monday morning, March 26, 2012, over President Barack Obama's health care overhaul, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, his Obama's signature domestic achievement. Seated from left to right ...

Arguing That Health Mandate Is Not a Tax, Except When It Is : Videos

Secretary Sebelius: Individual Mandate is Not a Tax Secretary Sebelius: Individual Mandate is Not a Tax Health And Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius directly contradicted the position of the US Department of Justice (DOJ) case that bears her ... Rated: 5     Duration: 64 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Tue, 28 Feb 2012 13:57:09 PST	Despite Supreme Court Argument, HHS Secretary Says Individual Mandate Is Not A Tax Despite Supreme Court Argument, HHS Secretary Says Individual Mandate Is Not A Tax Sec. Sebelius in front of the House Ways and Means Committee claims that the individual mandate is not a tax, though it does act like one. Despite ... Rated: -1     Duration: 74 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Tue, 28 Feb 2012 14:14:44 PST	Watch Presidents Budget Director Contradict Presidents Legal Argument for Obamacare Watch Presidents Budget Director Contradict Presidents Legal Argument for Obamacare OMB Acting Director Zients contradicts the Administration's argument before the Supreme Court on the constitutionality of the President's ... Rated: 4.8333335     Duration: 59 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Wed, 15 Feb 2012 09:22:18 PST	Obama Goes Toe-To-Toe With Stephanopoulos On "Tax Increases" Obama Goes Toe-To-Toe With Stephanopoulos On "Tax Increases" On "This Week," George Stephanopoulos and President Obama have a colorful discussion over Obama's health care reform proposal ... Rated: 4.3691406     Duration: 344 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Sun, 20 Sep 2009 07:33:31 PDT
Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 1/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But Cutting Health Care? Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 1/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But Cutting Health Care? Alex Covers the health care bill that is about to pass on christmas eve, and shows how this is nothing more then a road to tyranny & slavery ... Rated: 4.9107809     Duration: 649 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Sun, 20 Dec 2009 17:38:24 PST	Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 4/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But Cutting Health Care? Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 4/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But Cutting Health Care? Alex Covers the health care bill that is about to pass on christmas eve, and shows how this is nothing more then a road to tyranny & slavery ... Rated: 4.9216866     Duration: 485 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Sun, 20 Dec 2009 19:51:51 PST	Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 3/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But Cutting Health Care? Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 3/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But Cutting Health Care? Alex Covers the health care bill that is about to pass on christmas eve, and shows how this is nothing more then a road to tyranny & slavery ... Rated: 4.9080458     Duration: 536 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Sun, 20 Dec 2009 19:32:31 PST	Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 2/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But Cutting Health Care? Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 2/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But Cutting Health Care? Alex Covers the health care bill that is about to pass on christmas eve, and shows how this is nothing more then a road to tyranny & slavery ... Rated: 4.9170732     Duration: 658 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Sun, 20 Dec 2009 19:11:08 PST
Obama v Clinton on the Individual Mandate Mobile Obama v Clinton on the Individual Mandate Mobile Barack Obama -- the most articulate spokesman AGAINST the individual mandate--- IT MUST BE OPPOSED IN ANY HEALTH CARE REFORM BILL!!! Rated: 5     Duration: 62 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Thu, 12 Nov 2009 08:04:20 PST	110815 - Hyper Report 110815 - Hyper Report ... Obama: Individual Health Insurance Mandate 'Should Not Be Controversial' On his bus tour, Obama said that the individual health ... Rated: 4.972414     Duration: 170 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Mon, 15 Aug 2011 17:33:50 PDT	Constitutionality of the Health Insurance Mandate, video 5 Constitutionality of the Health Insurance Mandate, video 5 You made three points 1. You argued that Us v. Kahriger invalidates Bailey v. Drexel Furniture Co. because it found a gambling tax valid even ... Rated: -1     Duration: 182 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Wed, 16 Jun 2010 16:44:23 PDT	2009: Romney begs Obama: Embrace the Individual Mandate 2009: Romney begs Obama: Embrace the Individual Mandate THE STORY MATT DRUDGE WON'T REPORT(*): Throughout his campaign, Mitt Romney has tried to defend the individual mandate he signed into law in ... Rated: 3.4     Duration: 210 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Sat, 03 Mar 2012 12:33:54 PST
A Viewers Guide to Supreme Court Arguments on Health Care Law A Viewers Guide to Supreme Court Arguments on Health Care Law The Supreme Court is set to hear three days of arguments next week over challenges to the health reform law President Obama signed two years ago ... Rated: 5     Duration: 643 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Thu, 22 Mar 2012 18:09:40 PDT	Health Care Cases in 90 Seconds Health Care Cases in 90 Seconds March 16 (Bloomberg Law) -- The US Supreme Court will soon hear one of its most important cases in years -- the challenge to the Obama ... Rated: -1     Duration: 107 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Fri, 16 Mar 2012 12:33:25 PDT	US HOUSE Saturday Nov 11 :: Republicans Fight DEMOCRAT GOVERNMENT TAKEOVER Of OUR Health Care US HOUSE Saturday Nov 11 :: Republicans Fight DEMOCRAT GOVERNMENT TAKEOVER Of OUR Health Care C-SPAN coverage of TREASON IN PROGRESS in the US House Of Representatives on this day, Saturday, November 11, 2009 -- another day of infamy ... Rated: 3.6428571     Duration: 525 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Sat, 07 Nov 2009 13:33:26 PST	Mandated Reporting of Child Abuse Suspects - Fierce Debate Mandated Reporting of Child Abuse Suspects - Fierce Debate In the wake of the Penn State child abuse scandal some states are looking to mandate reporting of suspects. Should you go to jail if you don't ... Rated: 4.7280145     Duration: 702 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Sun, 25 Dec 2011 15:43:06 PST
Milton Friedman - Socialized Medicine Milton Friedman - Socialized Medicine Friedman explores the unsettling dynamics set into motion when government imposes itself into the health care system. (1978) Source: Milton ... Rated: 4.6759334     Duration: 578 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Mon, 22 Jun 2009 01:07:15 PDT	How to Fix Health Care: Lasik Surgery For The Medical Debate How to Fix Health Care: Lasik Surgery For The Medical Debate Make no mistake about it. Health care reform is coming. But what's the best way to fix our health care system, which is an inefficient ... Rated: 4.8051043     Duration: 523 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Wed, 02 Dec 2009 04:49:59 PST	Healthcare Bill Unconstitutional Federal Lawsuit filed in Pensacola Florida Healthcare Bill Unconstitutional Federal Lawsuit filed in Pensacola Florida maintain citizenship..." Vince Leger says it's not right, and its not constitutional. But others say we need to give health care reform a ... Rated: 5     Duration: 161 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Wed, 24 Mar 2010 08:28:24 PDT	Anti Healthcare Protest - Town Hall Health Care Reform Protesters - Tea Party Rally Anti Healthcare Protest - Town Hall Health Care Reform Protesters - Tea Party Rally Stag News footage of the Tea Party protesters from an 8/29/09 town hall meeting concerning health care reform. There's also a " ... Rated: 3.3737864     Duration: 389 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Sun, 30 Aug 2009 23:45:09 PDT
Opening Remarks at Senate Finance Committee Hearing with Sec. Sebelius on the Presidents Budget Opening Remarks at Senate Finance Committee Hearing with Sec. Sebelius on the Presidents Budget liberty is protected is through a full exemption for all religious institutions. At today's Finance Committee hearing, Sebelius could not say ... Rated: 3     Duration: 357 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Wed, 15 Feb 2012 10:00:07 PST	Health Reform Law to Face Constitutional Test in Supreme Court Health Reform Law to Face Constitutional Test in Supreme Court On Monday, the Supreme Court agreed to hear arguments next spring on the constitutionality of the health care reform law. Jeffrey Brown discusses ... Rated: 5     Duration: 470 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Mon, 14 Nov 2011 17:07:03 PST	Unfunded Mandates And Regulatory Overreach Unfunded Mandates And Regulatory Overreach Unfunded Mandates And Regulatory Overreach - House Oversight Committee - Rayburn HOB 2203 - 2011-02-15 - House Committee on Oversight and ... Rated: 5     Duration: 4480 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Tue, 15 Feb 2011 11:12:30 PST	GOPs Healthcare Repeal Strategy GOPs Healthcare Repeal Strategy Bill Democrats Healthcare Medicare Deficit Debt taxes taxpayers americans us health care private insurance mandate corporations public option ... Rated: 4.8833332     Duration: 174 seconds     Video type: YouTube     Hosted by: www.youtube.com on Tue, 23 Mar 2010 20:14:42 PDT
Duthel Intelligence Report. 2011 Libyan civil war Duthel Intelligence Report. 2011 Libyan civil war Hosted by: blip.tv	Obama Goes Toe-To-Toe With Stephanopoulos On "Tax Increases" Obama Goes Toe-To-Toe With Stephanopoulos On "Tax Increases" Duration: 344000 seconds Hosted by: YouTube	Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 1/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But ... Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 1/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But ... Duration: 649000 seconds Hosted by: YouTube	Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 4/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But ... Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 4/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But ... Duration: 485000 seconds Hosted by: YouTube
Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 2/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But ... Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 2/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But ... Duration: 658000 seconds Hosted by: YouTube	Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 3/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But ... Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 3/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But ... Duration: 536000 seconds Hosted by: YouTube	Universal Health Care Insurance & Neighborhood Healthcare Centers ... Universal Health Care Insurance & Neighborhood Healthcare Centers ... Duration: 2033000 seconds Hosted by: YouTube	Obama lied about health insurance. Obama lied about health insurance. Duration: 386000 seconds Hosted by: YouTube
Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 1/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But ... Alex Jones Tv {Sunday Edition} 1/4:Theyre Raising Taxes, But ... Duration: 649000 seconds Hosted by: YouTube	Healthcare Bill Unconstitutional Federal Lawsuit filed in ... Healthcare Bill Unconstitutional Federal Lawsuit filed in ... Duration: 649000 seconds Hosted by: YouTubeHosted by: YouTube	GLORIA ARROYO RIGHTS: RIGHT TO TRAVEL OR SIMPLY THE RIGHT TO ... GLORIA ARROYO RIGHTS: RIGHT TO TRAVEL OR SIMPLY THE RIGHT TO ... Duration: 649000 seconds Hosted by: YouTubeHosted by: YouTubeHosted by: YouTube	Roskam Votes To Rescue Economy From Job-Destroying Healthcare Bill Roskam Votes To Rescue Economy From Job-Destroying Healthcare Bill Duration: 649000 seconds Hosted by: YouTubeHosted by: YouTubeHosted by: YouTubeHosted by: YouTube
OBAMA STIMULUS - THE END OF NEANDERTHAL ECONOMICS? OBAMA STIMULUS - THE END OF NEANDERTHAL ECONOMICS? Duration: 565000 seconds Hosted by: YouTube	Debt Limit : Obama Bests GOP, Tea Party Via Budget Control Act Debt Limit : Obama Bests GOP, Tea Party Via Budget Control Act Duration: 565000 seconds Hosted by: YouTubeHosted by: YouTube	Featured episodes in Featured episodes in Duration: 565000 seconds Hosted by: YouTubeHosted by: YouTubeHosted by: blip.tv	Duthel Intelligence Report. 2011 Libyan civil war Duthel Intelligence Report. 2011 Libyan civil war Duration: 565000 seconds Hosted by: YouTubeHosted by: YouTubeHosted by: blip.tvHosted by: blip.tv

Arguing That Health Mandate Is Not a Tax, Except When It Is : Latest News, Information, Answers and Websites

Justices Hear Argument That Health Case Is ... - New York Times

5 hours ago ... The justices appeared receptive to arguments that the court could hear the ... which says taxpayers may not challenge taxes until they become due. ... for violating the health care law's individual mandate do not kick in until ...

Obama’s Lawyer Confuses Himself: Is the Mandate a Penalty or a Tax?

Is the individual mandate a penalty, or a tax? That was today’s question at the Supreme Court. Except that both ... Robert Long, to argue that the mandate was a tax. He didn’t get very far. “I would not argue that this statute is a perfect ...

Obama: Mandate is Not a Tax - ABC News - ABCNews.com: Daily News ...

But in our most spirited exchange, the President refused to accept the argument that a mandate to buy health insurance is equivalent to a tax.

Commerce Clause Is Coming to Town

Central to the issues before the court is the individual mandate, which requires most individuals to buy health insurance by ... And this budget not only tackles entitlements, but it also tackles tax reform. He wants to cut us down to two ...

Supreme Court Probably Won't Punt On Healthcare | Mother Jones

When Verilli argued that Americans could not be punished for not purchasing health insurance beyond being hit with the mandate-imposed "tax," Justice Stephen Breyer dryly observed, "why do you keep saying 'tax'?

Mitt Romney and the individual mandate: A highly misleading DNC ad

President Obama’s health-care law was largely built around the concept of an individual mandate ... as an argument, pretending that he is stating them as his own opinion. But Romney is not specifically endorsing Wyden-Bennett, except to ...

The Empire Slinks Back

Wheresoever the Roman conquers, he inhabits. -- Seneca Iraq has fallen. Saddams statues are face down in the dust. His evil tyranny is at an end. So -- can we, like, go home now? You didnt have to wait long for a perfect symbol of the fundamental weakness at the heart of the new American imperialism -- sorry, humanitarianism. Im talking about - Niall Ferguson article on America as imperial power, establishing capitalism and democracy in Iraq and other countries, by military force if necessary; says US has power to impose changes, but may lack stamina for long term occupation; contrasts British occupation of Iraq, which lasted from 1920 through 1932, but effectively until 1958 revolution; compares mindset of British imperial philosophy with that of Americas nation building; photos (L) - Niall Ferguson is Herzog professor of financial history at the Stern School of Business, New York University, and a senior research fellow of Jesus College, Oxford. He is the author of Empire: The Rise and Demise of the British World Order and the Lessons for Global Power. - By Niall Ferguson

Are Muslims Exempt from ObamaCare Health Insurance Mandate?

Are Muslims Exempt from ObamaCare Health Insurance Mandate? ... specifically exempted from the government mandate to purchase insurance, and also from the penalty tax ...

Government Arguing That Health Insurance Premiums Are Really Taxes ...

Government Arguing That Health Insurance Premiums Are Really Taxes? By Megan ... forward today, with the government trying to clarify how the mandate is a tax, (though not ...

History of the Individual Health Insurance Mandate, 1989-2010 ...

History of the health insurance mandate from ... tried to elevate, arguing that because I don’t force people to buy health care that I’m not ... an advance refundable tax ...

Your Guide To The Health Law At The Supreme Court, Day 1

KHN’s reporter inside the court, Stuart Taylor, tells Jackie Judd that all the justices, except one ... with the individual mandate for not having health insurance is NOT a tax. Tomorrow, youre going to be back here arguing it is a tax."

Supreme Court, Affordable Care Act: does the Anti-Injunction Act stop a mandate ruling until 2015?

The first argument ... not the latter type of suit, because Private Respondents’ “purpose” supposedly is “inextricably linked” to the alleged tax penalty. See Govt. AIA Br. 39-40. In particular, the Government claims that the mandate ...

High Court Hears First Day Of Health Law Arguments; Justices ...

Kaiser Health News is tracking coverage of the arguments, including reports about the justices' consideration of whether the Anti-Injuction Act would preclude their review of the legal challenges to the individual mandate. ... In an unusual twist, the Obama administration is now siding with the law's opponents and will argue the mandate is not a tax. The high court actually designated a Washington private attorney, Robert Long, to argue in favor of the tax question.

Obamacare and the Supreme Court: The Mandate Question

In fact, one can argue that the opposition to the individual mandate ... except in a few rare cases, been repelled by the Court. Again, lest anyone peg me a liberal in this area, I am not. I have written in the past that health care reform ...

Conservative Opponents Of The Individual Mandate, Meet ...

... yet to see it (well, except this dishonest attack on the health care mandate). ... In Mexico I pay a tax and get health ... consistency of those arguing against the mandate-- not ...

Brother, Can You Spare a Billion?; In Hard Times, Budget Makers Will Cut, Tax and Borrow

Money troubles, everybodys got money troubles. From Albany to Trenton, to the halls of power in New York City and Nassau County, state and local governments around the region are trying to figure out how to plug big deficits. Really big deficits. Budget-phobic? Take heart. This is not rocket science. It simply means that all these governments have - State and local governments in New York region face large budget deficits, and the choices they are making on spending cuts, taxes and borrowing are dictated as much by history and politics as by fiscal realities; situations in New Jersey, New York State, New York City and Nassau County; photo (M) - By MICHAEL COOPER

Health Care Lawsuits - Constitutionality Corner blog

2 hours ago ... The Tax Anti-Injunciton Act applies not only to "taxes," but also to other ... Except as provided in sections 6015 (e), 6212 (a) and (c), 6213 (a), ... Tomorrow you are going to be back and you will be arguing that the penalty is a tax. ... (2) a person fails to obtain health insurance as mandated by the law and is ...

Mike Dowty: Obamacare takes the stage

Without the mandate ... to purchase health insurance are not imposed until 2015. If the court determines these penalties to be a tax, it cannot take up the case until then. I’m going to predict that the court will not buy this argument.

Changing Tune, Administration Defends Insurance Mandate as a Tax ...

Administration officials say the tax argument is a linchpin of their legal case in defense of the health care overhaul and its individual mandate.

In Health Case, Combustible Mix Of Politics And Law

They assert that the laws mandate that Americans buy health insurance is unconstitutional. The 24 Republican governors, along with the GOP attorneys general in two states with Democratic governors, further argue ... Or A Tax? The court may not even ...

Democrats are accomplishing what Romney’s Opponents should have

Romney may not have ever uttered “I support a federal mandate ... the health care debate. Except for the first part, Romney actually said that Massachusetts could serve as the model for the rest of the country. It is all about the tax [liberal ...

BEING AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIA ALWAYS SEEMED SO FAR away and perhaps not so important. Suddenly, there was Secretary of State George P. Shultz flying off to Canberra, the Australian capital, to listen more carefully to what the folks down under had to say about global defense strategy. At parties in Manhattan, the learned were talking about great Australian films and - By Seymour Topping; Seymour Topping is the managing editor of The New York Times

ObamaCare: The White Elephant Is Still In The Room

Using past "judge made case law" as their argument as precedence ... for those corporate health care networks. Will Washington be putting all those homeless and jobless Americans who do not or cannot comply with the mandate in the privatized ...

Romney doubles down on argument that state health mandate is ...

Romney doubles down on argument that state health mandate is conservative ... House Republicans huddle to debate 2012 tax strategy; Medicare chiefs ...

NYT: Obama WH will argue ObamaCare mandate is a tax « Hot Air

NYT: Obama WH will argue ObamaCare mandate is a tax ... take a responsibility to get health insurance is absolutely not a tax ... A tax, except when it isn’t « Nan ...

Making the Complex Understandable: Obamacare Arguments at ...

4 hours ago ... "The National Federation of Independent Businesses and the 26 states argued that the health care mandate penalty is not a tax, and therefore ...

HealthCare Plaintiff Files for Bankruptcy with $4.5K in Medical Bills

Even if the Browns choose not to purchase Health Insurance - they are still using Health Services - and in the end someone is paying for it. Be that Charity or Tax Payers, that someone is "Us". All of us. So yet again as Limbaugh might argue in ...

Varied Takes On The Power Of The Word Slut

Again, this is an argument that has little to do with the words. He writes - Bozell writes: This is all about disingenuous politics. Liberals want this government-mandated controversy to be not about - government-mandate controversy to be not ...

Challenging Obamacare

Controlling one-sixth of the economy, theyre more than ever able to game the system by: • by 2018, imposing an excise tax ... Health Law Mandate," saying: The Times March 9 article titled, "White House Set to Shape Debate Over Health Law" omits a key ...

Quick Take — Court Seems Likely To Reach Merits Of Mandate's ...

The Supreme Court has just adjourned after its first day of arguments on the health care cases. Stay tuned for a full update around 2 p.m. and a Q&A at 3 p.m. But for now, here are ... The Solicitor General, Donald Verrilli, argued that the mandate is a tax for purposes of Congress's taxing power, but not a tax for purposes of the Anti-Injunction Act. That argument drew multiple hostile comments. Said Justice Alito, “Today you're arguing the penalty is not a tax. Tomorrow ...

Obama Admin. Argues in Court That Individual Mandate Is a Tax

... Florida-based lawsuit against the health care law, arguing ... version that Obama signed did not describe the mandate as a tax ... theyre all globalists (except a few).

Supreme Court Justices: Health Care 'Individual Mandate' Is Not A Tax

If the Supreme Court rules the individual mandate is not a tax then it will invalidate much of my argument that income tax collection is precedent and support for the individual mandate's constitutionality. It might be surprising to find out that both sides actually agree on this issue. Lawyers for ... The law, he added, “doesn't use the word tax once, except as a collection device.” Obama-appointed Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan questioned the limits and ...

Althouse: The big week of Obamacare oral arguments begins with ...

6 hours ago ... It's not a tax whenever you don't want it to be, and it is when you do. ... violating the mandate in the health care law —a penalty, not a tax — matters .... Cavuto laid it out this way on his show, but, except for you, that's the only ...

Individual Mandate - Health Policy Briefs

This is not the first time an individual mandate has been proposed at the .... Exemptions: Both bills would exempt certain people from penalties for failing to ... or criminal sanctions for tax evasion would not apply to the health insurance assessment. ... In the first category, supporters argue that an individual mandate is key to ...

When Republicans thought the individual mandate was a tax

... in other words, if you do not choose health insurance — this bill will actually tax you. ... associated with the individual mandate was NOT a tax. They were going to argue ...

The Constitutionality of the Individual Mandate for Health ...

Second, it is not actually a mandate. It is a tax, which people would not have to pay if they purchased health ... powerful, opponents have tried to argue that the tax ...

Court skeptical of tax argument on mandate? « Hot Air

4 hours ago ... Tags: individual health care mandate, obama, Obamacare, Supreme Court ... 2) If the mandate is not a tax under the AJA, that doesn't mean it's not a tax for ..... clauses relating to federal power except perhaps the bill of rights.

Republicans See an Opportunity to Fault Candidate Gore as Gasoline Prices Rise

Republicans in Congress have begun to blame the Clinton administration generally and Vice President Al Gore in particular for the recent jump in the price of gasoline, and that seems sure to become a hot issue in the presidential race. When prices started to rise, the administration was asleep at the wheel, Representative Dick Armey of Texas, - Republicans in Congress have begun to blame Clinton administration generally and Vice Pres Al Gore in particular for recent jump in gasoline prices, and that seems sure to become hot issue in presidential race (M)2 - By DAVID E. ROSENBAUM

Court skeptical of tax argument on mandate? « Hot Air

Philip Klein reports from the arguments being made at the Supreme Court today on the health-care reform plan, and the main argument for the constitutionality of its core individual mandate came under attack from the liberal wing ... Despite Obama's protestations during the ObamaCare debate that the mandate was not a tax, his team has been forced to argue that it in fact does qualify as a tax, since that's the only basis on which Congress can impose such a mandate.

Hazards of the Individual Health Care Mandate

Hazards of the Individual Health Care Mandate. By Glen ... at least there is a reasonable argument that a well-enforced mandate could ... 20 percent of the uninsured from the tax ...

Pregnant Immigrants Wait Out Policy Storm

The pregnant young women began to vanish from community health clinics in East Los Angeles several weeks ago, scattered by Gov. Pete Wilsons announcement that California would soon cut off prenatal care to illegal immigrants under the new Federal welfare law. Where the women have gone is uncertain. Most seem to have stayed home, assuming that - Californias plan to cut off prenatal care to illegal immigrants under new Federal welfare law causes pregnant women to vanish from health clinics; public-health officials predict they will eventually turn up in emergency rooms and neonatal intensive-care units, at far greater cost to public; say in addition to humanitarian and clinical considerations, it is extremely prudent financial decision not to let any go without adequate prenatal care; say they may be forced to either carve new resources for illegal immigrants from emaciated county health budgets or do nothing for women, knowing that state and Federal agencies will continue to cover costs of patients emergency care; lawyers for coalition of civil rights groups file for restraining order, trying to stop cutoff of funds by state on grounds that doing so would violate earlier Federal court ruling and California Constitution; chart; photo (M) - By TIM GOLDEN

How Obamacare Dramatically Increases the Cost of Insurance for Young Workers

The fine for not purchasing health insurance under PPACA is $95 per person in 2014 (or 1% of taxable income, whichever is greater), $325 in 2015 (or 2%), and $695 in 2016 (or 2.5%). Thereafter, the mandate ... central policy argument for the ...

Making the Complex Understandable: Obamacare Arguments at ...

"The National Federation of Independent Businesses and the 26 states argued that the health care mandate penalty is not a tax, and therefore does not fall under the Anti-Injunction Act. The Justice Department, interestingly, ...

THE TEXAS TRIBUNE; 20 Weeks in Which the Budget Held Sway

The 82nd Texas Legislatures regular session ends as it started, with lawmakers arguing about a shrunken state budget and redistricting. With Republicans operating with a supermajority in the House and a commanding majority in the Senate, there was little doubt that the G.O.P. would be able to impose its will. What was new was the power exerted by - By THE TEXAS TRIBUNE

Blogs | Mother Jones

2 hours ago ... "I would not argue that this statute is a model of clarity," Long grumbled. ... He maintained that the individual mandate is not a tax covered by the Tax ... (Federal money can't be used to pay for abortions except in the most extreme .... Congress can tax everyone and then provide them with health insurance ...

The PJ Tatler » SCOTUS Wraps First Day of ObamaCare Arguments

It looks like the court isn't interested in the argument that it can't even rule on ObamaCare until its tax-that-is-not-a-tax-except-when-Obama-says-it's-a-tax. Arguments will continue, and ... The comments and questions of the Justices during the 89-minute exchange left the distinct impression that they are prepared to rule on the constitutionality of the mandate that individuals must buy health insurance, and not push the issue off into the future. The exact route they would ...

What happened? The Limits of Rahmism

AS A DOZEN or so top White House officials gathered in Rahm Emanuels corner West Wing office one morning in early January, the presidents political director, Patrick Gaspard, reported on the latest poll numbers in Massachusetts. With less than two weeks until a special Senate election, the Republican candidate was gaining momentum -- just nine - Peter Baker is a White House correspondent for The Times and a contributing writer for the magazine. - By PETER BAKER

Why Obamacare mandate penalty can’t be a tax

... in the mandate. The purported tax is on not buying health ... argument against the health care mandate. That is not correct. ... define it, except to say that its not ...

Supreme Court Begins Oral Arguments On Obamacare | FDL News ...

6 hours ago ... The other arguments for the mandate have to do with the ability for ... the mandate is “necessary and proper” to the functioning of the health care .... The Obamacare mandate, however is NOT a tax. ... Except nothing is free.

ObamaCare’s Mandate Is Not A Tax, Except When It Is

ObamaCare’s Mandate Is Not A Tax, Except When ... during the health care debate that the individual mandate is “absolutely” not a tax increase. ... Some argue that Obama ...

Obama Flip-Flops on the Individual Mandate (Again) | Cato @ Liberty

Administration officials say the tax argument is a linchpin of their legal case in defense of the health care overhaul and its individual mandate, now being challenged in ...

Your Guide To The Health Law At The Supreme Court, Day 1 ...

The first day's arguments focused on the Anti-Injunction Act and whether the court can rule on the case before a penalty is imposed on those who do not have health insurance. KHN's reporter ... He was speaking to Donald Verrilli, the solicitor general who is arguing for the government, and he said more or less in so many words: "Mr. Verrilli, today you're arguing that the penalty for not complying with the individual mandate for not having health insurance is NOT a tax.

The New American Consensus; Government of, by and For the Comfortable

The other day, while Washington was going up in flames, the two candidates for what is probably the most important office at stake in the 1998 elections, the governorship of California, held a debate in Sacramento. Gray Davis, the Democrat, is a veteran liberal politician whose fate it is to be known for the goodness of fit between his first name - Nicholas Lemann article on relatively new but powerful working consensus between Republicans and Democrats on most major issues; cites race for center by candidates of both parties around nation; sees new consensus forged through heavy use of public-opinion polls; says view spawned by Great Depression that big government is needed to protect people from worst vagaries of market economy has been replaced; says most Americans now believe government should serve middle class, but that middle class has no obligation to commit time or money to larger national projects; sampling of American family portraits (L) - Nicholas Lemann is the national correspondent for The Atlantic Monthly. He has just completed a book about meritocracy in America. - By Nicholas Lemann

Should Supreme Court arguments be on TV?

It’s a tax ... I’m not. The most controversial and important issue of the moment is whether or not to provide health care to all in our country who need it, and if so, how to do it. The once bipartisan idea of an individual mandate ...

Issue & Argument; HC Mandate = Tax? « Furthermore

On the Obama Administration Arguing in Court That the Health Care Individual Mandate Is a Tax… Issue. In order to protect the new national Health Care ...

THE TEXAS TRIBUNE; 20 Weeks in Which the Budget Held Sway

The 82nd Texas Legislatures regular session ends as it started, with lawmakers arguing about a shrunken state budget and redistricting. With Republicans operating with a supermajority in the House and a commanding majority in the Senate, there was little doubt that the G.O.P. would be able to impose its will. What was new was the power exerted by - By THE TEXAS TRIBUNE

Arguing That Health Mandate Is Not a Tax, Except When It Is http://t.co/f4EewcXy
From: nytimeshealth - Source: The New York Times

RT @freeNYTimes: Arguing That Health Mandate Is Not a Tax, Except When It Is - http://t.co/i6lzgvAH - #health
From: HumesBastard - Source: freeNYTimes

RT @freeNYTimes: Arguing That Health Mandate Is Not a Tax, Except When It Is - http://t.co/i6lzgvAH - #health
From: lippard - Source: freeNYTimes

Arguing That Health Mandate Is Not a Tax, Except When It Is - http://t.co/uUNlEMAy - #health
From: freeUnnamedNews - Source: Free Unnamed News 2

Arguing That Health Mandate Is Not a Tax, Except When It Is - http://t.co/i6lzgvAH - #health
From: freeNYTimes - Source: freeNYTimes

#News Arguing That Health Mandate Is Not a Tax, Except When It Is: The Justice Department has long been in an aw... http://t.co/ArmxC6eu
From: nytimesfeeds - Source: twitterfeed